Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

50% bring John Lennon and George Harrison back to life and re-form The Beatles today

50% go back to 1963 and go to every Beatles concert from then until 1970 when they broke up

Would you rather...

50%
509,205 disagree
Bring John Lennon and George Harrison back to life and re-form The Beatles today
50%
519,209 agree
Go back to 1963 and go to every Beatles concert from then until 1970 when they broke up

Beatles

added by Ross
Loading Comments…
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by Either moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

412 comments

  • 288

    Katie

    8 years ago

    Wish there was a neither option on this one. Most overrated band of all time.

    • 58

      Kendall Walls

      8 years ago

      finally someone who agrees

    • 79

      SonicDude203

      8 years ago

      wrong one direction is the most overrated band of all time PS.- if you don't like em, why'd you answer the question dumbass?

    • 53

      Tommapar

      7 years ago

      Because if he didn't he wouldn't be able to comment ;)

    • 11

      Anne

      7 years ago

      So true.

    • 21

      Tom Phillips

      7 years ago

      Fucking kill yourself...

    • 15

      Raphael Motta

      7 years ago

      Fuck you..

    • 4

      ThatGuySam

      7 years ago

      rolling stones are way better

    • 36

      Freddie Mercury

      7 years ago

      'Overrated' oh, they only defined rock music and paved the way for all bands after them. People call them over-rated without knowing what they did.

    • 6

      Carbon

      7 years ago

      Fuck you

    • 8

      IdRather

      7 years ago

      @SonicDude203 you disapoint me. you do not simply skip a question because you don't like either option. If you did that, you wouldn't have to eat dog treats OR cat food, and you could have your legs AND your arms, etc.

    • 7

      Sam

      7 years ago

      @Freddie Mercury All they did was play the music black people were playing for a decade and be white. They were not great innovators of music. Except for George he brought more eastern influences which was pretty innovative.

    • 4

      Johnlocked

      7 years ago

      Agreed. At least with this option, I never have to actually listen to their shite music.

    • 4

      Jooce

      7 years ago

      The beatles were original, whoever said they copied off of "black" people. I doubt anyone who hates them ever listened to any of their songs further down their career.

    • 5

      shaszbotter

      7 years ago

      fuck of everyone the beatles are the best band ever and were verry important for modern music they were so popular they weren`t allowed to come to some towns cause the security couldn`t handel it and now i`m going listen to the beatles cause at least that is good

    • 0

      kangcool09

      6 years ago

      HATER COMETS COMING WHEN I SAY:beetles suck..

    • 0

      kangcool09

      6 years ago

      *cough*nope the best is jackson 5 *cough cough*

    • 1

      Dalailthis

      6 years ago

      Atleast it's not Dupstep.

    • 1

      Alex

      4 years ago

      Katie are u stupid or something

    • 0

      chickenpanda

      4 years ago

      fuck off dude

    • 2

      PuzzelMaster123

      4 years ago

      i didnt care i just picked

    • 1

      UnafraidKitty96

      4 years ago

      omg ikr

    • 0

      ExhaustedRuins

      4 years ago

      IKR their music is actually boring??? not just that but there was so much drama evolving around them and it makes me glad that they broke up lol

    • 0

      ExhaustedRuins

      4 years ago

      plus i was forced to listen to THREE of their albums over and over and i literally wanted to jump out the window (my dad just started playing the beatles btw consider yourselves lucky that you dont have a parent who's OBSESSED) and their songs literally all sounded exactly the same. i dont see what all the hype is about. Sure i like how they "paved" a way for more bands but that doesnt mean that they were the best in history??? the who and the rolling stones also paved a way for other bands its not just them.

    • 1

      TacoCat1017

      4 years ago

      Still better than the shit bands nowadays

    • 1

      BlameTheNarwhals

      4 years ago

      Back in their day, they were legend. If you were living back then and didn't have everything you had today, you would do anything to bring them back.

    • 4

      Kitty K

      4 years ago

      What?! They begun every single boy band to this day, they are the inspiration for most. They were awesome, back in the days... they were like lit. And no, they're songs are not all the same

    • 0

      Dash

      4 years ago

      bro

    • 0

      AJ;)

      4 years ago

      Many popular bands, singers, and music genres were influenced by them. Without the Beatles, they wouldn't exist. MJ was even inspired by Paul Mccartney (beatle member).

    • 0

      AJ;)

      4 years ago

      They also had a bigger fanbase than 5sos and One direction garbage

    • 0

      KawaiiPotato

      4 years ago

      stuff

    • 0

      KawaiiPotato

      4 years ago

      *STFU

    • 0

      Sableyesam

      4 years ago

      fuck off

    • 0

      epicsporkmaster

      4 years ago

      no offence Katie,but Fuck you to hell

    • 0

      Thunder Streak

      4 years ago

      You can go shut your face you disrespectuf twat.

    • 0

      Fuzzy Slippers

      3 years ago

      So many nine-year-olds. The lack of maturity is draining my tolerance. Also, I have to say that now the Beatles wouldn't potentially be as good as they were.

    • 0

      Evalgra

      3 years ago

      This comment section has a little too much salt, if you know what I'm saying.

    • 0

      Harambe

      3 years ago

      @Katie gtfoh lil kid. U don't know shit about music

    • 0

      George

      3 years ago

      Beatles are beasts

    • 0

      Kitkatlovesgaming34

      3 years ago

      OMG I MISS THIS BAND SO MUCH AHHHHHH

    • 0

      Nobody

      3 years ago

      FUCK YOU

    • 0

      Bro4

      3 years ago

    • 0

      GrumpyBastard

      2 years ago

      Listen to Eleanor Rigby and Help and say that again.

    • 0

      GrumpyBastard

      2 years ago

      Also, you just want them to be dead? Dickheads

    • 0

      Jebus Crist

      2 years ago

      ASSHOLES!!!

    • 0

      magical ronicorn

      2 years ago

      Hahahahahahaha. Oh you were serious.

    • 0

      Evalgra

      2 years ago

      Going back in time > starting a zombie apocalypse

    • 0

      Liam

      1 year ago

      FUCK YOU

    • 0

      Dilanep

      1 year ago

      IT I A THOUGHT CRIIME TO SHIT ON THE BEATLES, FUCK YOU!

    • 0

      - J U I c E E -

      1 year ago

      HOW DARE YOU OMG THE BEATLES ARE THE GREATEST

    • 0

      Sahaj Kasturi

      5 months ago

      Fuck off mate

  • 45

    Sammy Erickson

    8 years ago

    It wouldn't be the same today. I've always dreamed of seeing them in their prime.

    • 4

      Vampn

      6 years ago

      But only you would listen to them, that's a bit selfish.

    • 1

      Sammy Erickson

      6 years ago

      It never said I was the only one to go back! You can come too!

    • 1

      Micah Frazier

      6 years ago

      Exactly it's better to see them in their prime years

  • 23

    Raptorsayshi

    8 years ago

    They lived their lifes. The actual world sucks. (musically speaking)

  • 23

    Cosmic Hawke

    8 years ago

    I'd rather live in the present day and be able to bring people back to life

    • 1

      Wibbly Wobbly

      4 years ago

      Anyone who chose red is one of the kids who shouts "le wrong generation"

  • 21

    Tyler

    8 years ago

    i think it'd be cool to show kids these days what real music sounded like

    • 8

      Nic Feild

      8 years ago

      Yes, thank you!!!!!

    • 6

      Sam

      7 years ago

      Yes because the music you like is the only thing that is really music.

    • 1

      ExhaustedRuins

      4 years ago

      their music made me feel really uncomfortable and bored. I like my music better. Also it's probs because you listen to the wrong music sometimes?? like stop hating on today's music because you know that new song from sia?? that is actually a really good song. You know The Moth and the Flame?? Their music is beautiful. Stop complaining please because thats not true. Sure a lot of it sucks but a lot of it is amazing too.

    • 1

      jacksepticguy

      4 years ago

      Well Tyler, is forcing your opinion of good music on children so that they are deprived of musical independence nice?

  • 12

    drex64

    8 years ago

    Both? Lol I'm a huge beatles fan

    • 1

      Grace

      4 years ago

      Yeah, but if you resurrect John and George, don't you think they wouldn't be as talented?

  • 11

    Jacky Wang

    7 years ago

    Idiotic people saying they're the most overrated band of all time, that's because they were the first of their kind, the first 4-piece band that had such a huge fanbase, the first band that broke the boundaries and introduced modern rock into the world, England was the fuckign epicenter of the ENTIRE world's culture, never underestimate what they did for music, you might not like the music they make, but at that time, it was revolutionary, you wouldn't have a lot of the music you'd have today if if weren't for the Beatles. Just because you don't know why they were so popular doesn't mean they're overrated, there's a LOT of musical history and critical acclaim behind the Beatles, so before you listen to your Lady Gaga or Lionel Richie, your Earth wind and fire or Foo Fighters, without the Beatles, we'd still get Cliff Richard's "Summer Holiday" playing on our radio.

    • 1

      Castiel

      7 years ago

      The problem in your argument is that we can only hypothesize what the music industry would have been like without them. Other bands very well may have survived and even thrived without their existence. I chose blue because then I wouldn't be forced to hear any of their music.

    • 0

      jerem

      4 years ago

      look at those four agrees

    • 0

      ExhaustedRuins

      4 years ago

      no because they literally sound boring. i hate it. their music is really uninteresting and random. it makes me uncomfortable. i dont want anything to do with them.

    • 0

      ExhaustedRuins

      4 years ago

      also how can you be so ignorant????? it wasn't just them. It was also the who, the rolling stones, etc. Do you seriously think they were a "legend" because they were "totally the only ones" who helped music to this extent, and yet everyone is like "the music today sucks" maybe its because they caused that??? maybe they just made it worse idk but i cant imagine them coming back. if anyone even mentions the beatles to me i will immediately suspect that they're a boring person who likes to live in the past. dull.

    • 2

      Grace

      4 years ago

      Sorry to burst your bubble two years ago Castiel, but Jackie Wayne has a great point. The Beatles had people that could be your grandma screaming, chasing, even getting arrested for trying to reach them. So, before you decide to hate comment on the Beatles, try listening to some of their music instead o judging them. Stevie Wonders would have been nothing if it weren't for the Beatles. Think about it.

  • 9

    TrotPilgrim

    8 years ago

    I prefer The Beatles later stuff, after they stopped playing live shows in 1966.

    • 0

      Jooce

      7 years ago

      Same.

    • 0

      SlothsAreLove13

      4 years ago

      I do like Rubber Soul a lot tho

    • 0

      Grace

      4 years ago

      Yes, but some of their early stuff like Help and rubber soul were really good. That you can't deny. But I say that if I go back, I would be able to listen to their stuff before Paul couldn't hit the high notes. Plus, remember if you bring them back there's the Yoko Ono component. No offense to Yoko, but her music is not Beatles, I can tell you that much. Plus, you also have George Harrison, who quite frankly would probably team up with Ringo and start the money argument. You would also have to deal with the old men component and you don't want these beloved people miserable! Haters back off! Even if you disagree with me and think the Beatles suck, each of them took different paths and you might take interest in one of them separately. Also, whoever wrote this, the Beatles were official in 1961. They were with Pete Best with the same manager. That is the difference. Also, all the who and stones fans, well, your bands wouldn't have made as much profit if it weren't for the fab four. That's why I appreciate Elvis, buddy holly, Chuck Berry, etc for inspiring the Beatles if it weren't for anything else. Please no hate comments! Thanks!

  • 8

    LogicFTW

    8 years ago

    I wish both was an option

  • 6

    Ali

    8 years ago

    don't you think everyone would be more alarmed and terrified if one day the beatles simply came back to life? wouldn't the beatles themselves be terrified? i doubt much music would be made.

  • 6

    WentwoJ

    8 years ago

    i only picked this one because it's not like I'd be able to hear them if i went to one of their concerts back then. All the screaming and crying maniacs...

    • 1

      moona87

      7 years ago

      There were paramedics at their concerts because girls would faint and stuff, so bringing them back now would probably be a little better

    • 0

      ExhaustedRuins

      4 years ago

      bringing them back now would confuse things and it would become cruel to all those who were once fans. I wouldn't care as long as i dont have to listen to them. They'd probs be too old anyways

    • 1

      DietCyanide

      4 years ago

      Yeah and they stopped touring in '64

  • 5

    Joost Bom

    7 years ago

    I couldn't realy decide both are cool options!

  • 4

    Apotheosis Sin Jones

    7 years ago

    I had to go red I dont want there shitty music coming back

  • 4

    Matty

    7 years ago

    I was born where the beatles where born it would be nice to have that kind of recognition as a city LIVERPOOL FTW

  • 4

    Hannah

    8 years ago

    Are you allowed to warn John..?

    • 1

      Grace

      4 years ago

      If you're lucky enough to have him hear over the screaming girls. Also, I think he suffered hearing loss because he married yoko ono. Horrible voice that woman has.

  • 4

    Jelle Wijers

    8 years ago

    I don't think zombie beatles are a very good idea...

  • 4

    beerbaron7

    8 years ago

    I think the past 30 years would have been more interesting if John Lennon had still been alive...so I'd bring him back for a bit.

    • 1

      Grace

      4 years ago

      Yeah, but then you'd be forced to hear a screaming ego maniac singing horribly beside him. Hint: it's yoko ono.

  • 4

    Bill Jones

    8 years ago

    I'd bring them back to life. Go back? You wouldn't be able to enjoy the music without a million girls screaming at the top of their lungs!

  • 3

    Gunnar Riedlinger

    8 years ago

    Let it be.

  • 2

    Daniel

    4 years ago

    bring a nice cinema quality 4k cinema camera with you! and shitloads of memory! Become the richest person ever!

  • 2

    Zack Glaspy

    7 years ago

    If you voted red, you're selfish.

  • 2

    Brandy Naroznick

    7 years ago

    Fuck ya. Experience the 60's and the Beatles in their prime!

  • 2

    Lisa Wolf

    8 years ago

    they kill themselfs right after i brought them back as soon as they turned on the radio. so better go back and visit the concerts.

  • 2

    Shawn

    8 years ago

    The world needs the beatles now, and I'm not a huge fan of them

    • 0

      Grace

      4 years ago

      Yes u r! You will realize it soon enough Shawn from three years ago!

  • 0

    COOLMAN

    2 weeks ago

    if you bring back John Lennon and George Harrison back, they'll need to bring back their music style. BUT the 2nd answer will not do more work so the logic stands that the 2nd answer is correct

  • 1

    Samuel

    4 years ago

    I'd go back as long as I could take my iPhone 6S Plus with me and I could travel back to the future afterwards.

  • 1

    Arizona Babe

    4 years ago

    Love this band

  • 1

    Gloria

    4 years ago

    :/ i asked my sister to choose cause i could not

  • 1

    Blackguard

    4 years ago

    Considering I am what one would consider black, you can understand my trepidation with going back in time.

  • 1

    YouShallNotPass

    6 years ago

    They broke up for a reason.

  • 1

    Tyler Kane

    6 years ago

    Free love era for sure! beatles concerts now a days would be full of stuck up hipster chicks

  • 1

    Marcin Michał Sleziona

    7 years ago

    What bout Ringo Starr? Ain't nobody got time fo dat

  • 1

    Jaffa cake

    7 years ago

    For the good of the world.

  • 1

    viveh

    7 years ago

    i fucking hate the beatles

  • 1

    Conorca

    7 years ago

    You couldnt hear them properly on concerts and people were crazy at them #beatlemania

  • 1

    Alejandro Baragana

    7 years ago

    I hope u all realize the beatles only had a handful of live shows. And most of the were hardly audible because of the screaming.

  • 1

    jazcaz98

    7 years ago

    Pffft I'm thinking in the ways of The Doctor.

  • 1

    Foofiekinz

    7 years ago

    Because im selfish

  • 1

    Karla Daniela Garcia

    7 years ago

    then save John and tell George to smoke less

  • 1

    Juanita

    7 years ago

    This is serious guys

  • 1

    raphadiao

    8 years ago

    ahahhaa funny

  • 1

    Ryan Ferris

    8 years ago

    OMG! Yous dont know how many times i dream of this

  • 1

    emdyey

    8 years ago

    Are you kidding me? Sure it's awesome to get to watch The Beatles perform at their prime, but 7 years of following them in concerts constantly would eventually get old (and could make you practically deaf with all those decibels pounding at your ear drums). Bringing them back to life in the present would still mean being able to appreciate their past albums, PLUS having them make new ones. Win-win.

  • 1

    Jason Buret

    8 years ago

    let them bring back good music and how cud u be so selfish to not save their lives -.-

  • 1

    RealityWarping

    8 years ago

    It would be so cool to see what they'd be like together now. People will never learn what music was like if it's just you to go see the concerts.

  • 0

    Fire Ball

    3 months ago

    I LOVE THE BEATLES I WOULD NONSTOP LISTEN TO LETITBE

  • 0

    MidgetJesus

    4 months ago

    we need them right now

  • 0

    racer194

    5 months ago

    This is a hard one...

  • 0

    buttholelicker69

    5 months ago

    people fucking died at beatles concerts

  • 0

    Zach

    1 year ago

    Forget the beatles I'll just stay in 1963 and do 60's shit

Load More

Tip: Use the arrow keys to navigate between questions.

Recently Answered

Either Mobile

Either is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android