Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

60% Take the Cinnamon Challenge

40% Take the Gallon Challenge

Would you rather...

60%
819,155 agree
Take the Cinnamon Challenge
40%
551,687 disagree
Take the Gallon Challenge

Dairy or Cinnamon

added by Brendan
Loading Comments…

Google some videos before you make your decision. Hint: the gallon challenge involves milk.

Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by Either moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

635 comments

  • 77

    Danielrockerr

    4 years ago

    The cinnamon challenge is easy I did it on my first try.

    • 26

      icecreamjello

      4 years ago

      Me too! It's soo much easier than people say it is...

    • 28

      Bob Smith

      4 years ago

      Are you serious. I felt like I was going to die.

    • 54

      Ricardo Aguilar

      4 years ago

      What's the point of a challenge if it's not difficult?

    • 21

      Destruction

      4 years ago

      Do you have a third lung?

    • 5

      William

      4 years ago

      I did it on my second try. Stung like a b*tch, but was otherwise not that bad.

    • 2

      Mimi Glory

      4 years ago

      The cinnamon challenge sounds EASY....

    • 4

      pmaguire13

      4 years ago

      it wasn't hard all you have to do is moisten it up

    • 24

      Yourmother196

      4 years ago

      But you can die on the cinnamon challenge

    • 12

      Marius Alexe

      3 years ago

      I'm not going on the easy way

    • 10

      melissa

      3 years ago

      You do realise it's against the rules of the challange to add water, if you drink, you've given up. The whole point of the challenge is to try swallow it. And also, you can die from it but only if you refuse to give up, which i would.

    • 14

      Jake Miller

      3 years ago

      It's easy as fuck if you're not retarded enough to inhale it, that's what causes everyone the discomfort. It's more technique than anything, to make sure you wet all the cinammon with your saliva so the small dust particles don't spread into your lungs, possible also causing hypoxia of the lungs.

    • 1

      TraxInfo

      3 years ago

      Awww yis gonna take the cinnamon challenge cause i did the gallon challenge, pfft

    • 4

      Flying pancakes

      3 years ago

      Do the Cinnamon Challenge... WITH COCAINE!

    • 3

      [deleted]

      3 years ago

      Considering I'm lactose intolerant, I wouldn't be able to take the gallon challenge without feeling like my stomach's dying. True, the reason why you cough up the cinnamon is because you're not supposed to ingest that much of it, but I think I'd rather cough than feel like my insides are throwing punches.

    • 2

      Kat

      3 years ago

      Pretend to put the cinnamon in your mouth, then 'spit' it out. Mission accomplished. No pain :D

    • 0

      Glaceon999

      3 years ago

      Just lick, swallow, lick, swallow, repeat.

    • 6

      Warrior cat fan

      1 year ago

      CINNAMON IS MADE OF GROUND UP TREE BARK PEOPLE AND IT WILL KILL YOU

    • 2

      Crashaunt

      1 year ago

      @Warrior cat fan it doesnt kill you...also i also like warrors

    • 4

      Mango the Mongo

      1 year ago

      sure, almost die and have injuries in your lung rather than throw up and have stomachache for max 1 hour...

    • 6

      ZJBlah

      1 year ago

      IT COULD KILL YOU!

    • 2

      philtoplester

      1 year ago

      I like how the person who made this said the gallon challenge involves milk and their name is Brendan

    • 2

      JoaoChus

      1 year ago

      already did it

    • 2

      hiromason

      1 year ago

      you could die

    • 1

      linkguy3305

      1 year ago

      CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG CHUG

    • 0

      Lin

      1 year ago

      I did as well, yeah.

    • 1

      sourcupcake123

      1 year ago

      If the average stomach holds 1/2 a gallon, mine probably holds 1/4. BLEGGG

    • 0

      IceCream

      1 year ago

      True but very dangerous it could cause lung problems though

    • 1

      JerrytheSlime

      1 year ago

      why the fuck you lying, why the fuck you lying

    • 1

      logan

      11 months ago

      stop lying how did anyone even like that comment to many people believe in the most stupid things ever that I knew were fake when i was literally five.

    • 1

      NightVisions101

      10 months ago

      it is so easy

    • 0

      Nigger

      10 months ago

      ik its not that bad lmao

    • 2

      Kelran

      9 months ago

      The cinnamon challenge could kill you.

    • 1

      Crystal Damel

      8 months ago

      i did it on my second try - im still alive.

    • 0

      JackChase

      6 months ago

      you could of died

    • 0

      tommy

      5 months ago

      whats the point of getting spice in your lungs?

    • 0

      Dakota

      3 months ago

      Like all u got to do is NOT breath in the slightest est AT ALL then u complete it ;)

    • 0

      ITZ_LIZZIE

      3 months ago

      i did the cinamon challenge when i was a kid. (without knowing)

    • 0

      Pepito

      2 months ago

      im gay

    • 1

      Alec Scorer

      1 month ago

      Im Only 15 It could kill me because of my health

    • 1

      Carolynn

      1 week ago

      well the Cinnamon if it gets into your lungs it could possibly kill you a girl has done it and she sided or something happened because it got into her lungs and she couldn't breathe just be thankful it didn't happen to you and don't take it offensive in any way please don't but don't say stuff like that saying "ohh it was easy i did it on my first try" because it encourages other people to do it and like i said please don't take it offensively ok thank you if you didn't get mad or anything bye!

  • 28

    Fabian

    5 years ago

    Surely, throwing up is better than possibly dying

    • 2

      CarpFoon

      1 year ago

      i've already done both. the cinammon challenge is a major dick. to all those who say it's easy, or you've done it first/second try, bs. or you just got lucky.

    • 0

      Carolynn

      1 week ago

      thats exactly what i said i so agree

  • 21

    GareBear

    6 years ago

    I can drink a 2 liter in under 20 minutes. I can handle a gallon of milk.

    • 31

      SAUCY SCOTSMAN

      5 years ago

      You would think, but gallon is a LOT thicker than soda.

    • 43

      SAUCY SCOTSMAN

      5 years ago

      Shit, *milk is thicker I meant.

    • 27

      xNervex

      5 years ago

      It is actually impossible to drink 1 gallon of milk in 1 hour and not throw up.

    • 21

      Daniel Finley

      5 years ago

      No, it's not. I've done it.

    • 17

      jack notman

      4 years ago

      In australia people do the gallon challenge in 1 minute . . . and they do it in public cause' they think it's cool

    • 12

      KilltheHobos

      4 years ago

      Milk has more fat in it, it takes more time to break down and be processed. Therefore you don't just pee it out as fast as you would water, soda, or juice. It's a lot harder.

    • 4

      Diddly

      4 years ago

      I did both in one night.

    • 9

      Triston36921

      4 years ago

      It's literally impossible, the human body can't handle it, and you'd throw up.

    • 8

      JessePinkman

      4 years ago

      i'm calling bull shit on that.

    • 2

      Yukira

      4 years ago

      but, i've done it?

    • 19

      peeter

      4 years ago

      human stomach can hold about 1,5 - 3,5 litres of food. if you can drink a gallon of milk without throwing up, you're probably a fat ass and your stomach stretched out from all the shit you eat.

    • 6

      wartpig

      4 years ago

      im a skinny guy and i drink alot of milk anyways. i down almost half a gallon in the mornings and i can eat endlessly. so it wouldnt be a stretch to down a gallon in an hour

    • 2

      Mcman117

      3 years ago

      Milk is way thicker than soda

    • 0

      Jp Masters

      3 years ago

      You have to drink without stopping

    • 2

      Jp Masters

      3 years ago

      Drink no stop

    • 1

      Jp Masters

      3 years ago

      Drink no stop

    • 1

      Jp Masters

      3 years ago

      Drink no stop

    • 0

      Much Doge

      3 years ago

      You throw up

    • 0

      COG BloodRusher

      3 years ago

      In the gallon challange you have to consume it in under 5 minutes wiyhout puking or any bipe coming oit pf your mouth and you wpuld havr piked brcause all the carbonation it would and sugars mskinh you puke so therefore i claim a bluff

    • 0

      Craig Hoague

      3 years ago

      Dude i can down a 2 liter of soda in under 5 min but i did 1/2 gallon of milk and i thought my stomach was gonna burst open

    • 0

      Mattyg337

      3 years ago

      Who can't drink a 2 liter in under 20 minutes?

    • 0

      Urthumbvsmine

      2 years ago

      Agreed it's not extremely hard

    • 0

      Urthumbvsmine

      2 years ago

      Agreed it's not extremely hard

    • 1

      Morgan James

      1 year ago

      FUCK YEA BRUH

    • 1

      epiccracft1000

      1 year ago

      i live on milk true story

    • 0

      HazardousInferno

      1 year ago

      Soda tastes WAY better.

  • 14

    ChalngeAccepted

    5 years ago

    I'm deadly allergic to milk, so I think it's rather obvious why I chose the way I did....

    • 4

      Iggy

      4 years ago

      Soy Milk?

    • 0

      [deleted]

      3 years ago

      Soy milk is nice... despite all those ads about "soy aftertaste face"

  • 13

    otterrose

    5 years ago

    I've done the gallon challenge, and the cinnamon challenge. Throwing up (gallon challenge) is so much better than feeling like you're going to cough up a lung.

    • 2

      Cerulean

      3 years ago

      Gallon Challenge completed, didn't even vomit. It was a close one though.

    • 1

      JB1625

      1 year ago

      People are such idiots "An hour isn't that long" people say that all the time but it is super long they should take their time for pete sake!!!!

  • 12

    love_me_olivia

    4 years ago

    i LOVE cinnamon

    • 1

      madifline

      4 years ago

      Ya won't like it after you try the cinnamon challenge >.>

  • 9

    conny2011

    6 years ago

    i've never taken either of these challenges, but the cinnamon challenge sounds nasty

    • 1

      IIMzBoss

      5 years ago

      TAKE THEM!!!

    • 3

      love1panic

      4 years ago

      I threw up. It's pretty bad.

    • 1

      Kat Nutkin

      4 years ago

      I found it fine, and wanted more...

    • 0

      kyra

      4 years ago

      dun it u cough loads an it all cums out everywhere its nice but reely strong i can spell btw but cant b boverd now i did both

    • 0

      MinecraftPonieZ

      3 years ago

      If you've never seen these challenges go on my bff's youtube page KittyJ76 plus think the best one we did together was the gallon challenge!

    • 0

      fallen_petals

      3 years ago

      The gallon challenge is actually harder and more disgusting (IMO). It involves drinking a gallon of milk without stopping in under 5 minutes. This has a high chance of leading to puking. I've done the cinnamon challenge before and I was able to do it on the first try. Some of my friends started coughing out the cinnamon dust but that was the worst that happened. And one did it like 6 times until she was able to complete the challenge.

  • 6

    AdorableCarnage

    4 years ago

    You can get lung scarring and choke to death in the cinnamon challenge.

  • 6

    noodle

    5 years ago

    the gallon almost always results in puke, doesnt it?

  • 5

    BERSERK

    4 years ago

    at least u wouldnt die from the gallon challenge...

    • 0

      Pablo

      2 months ago

      Yeah you are totally right on that one

  • 5

    Aiden

    5 years ago

    Done the cinnamon challenge. So obviously cinnamon challenge.

    • 3

      Jackie680015

      3 years ago

      300 people have DIED because of the cinnamon challenge =[

  • 5

    MyNameIsKali

    5 years ago

    Lactose intolerant here. I'd rather cough a ton for an hour than get sick for three days.

  • 4

    Unicyclist

    4 years ago

    I am extremely scared of vomiting

    • 5

      Iggy

      4 years ago

      I am extremely scared of potentially coughing up a lung.

  • 4

    n7soldier

    4 years ago

    I'm pregnant with a huge milk craving. I've got this, guise.

  • 4

    Poohunter

    4 years ago

    I took the cinnamon challenge. You're throat hurts like hell after that for a long time. Never again...

  • 3

    #Asha

    2 years ago

    I love cinnamon

  • 3

    BluntSword

    4 years ago

    I hate milk.

  • 3

    nicole

    4 years ago

    The gallon challenge can mess up your kidneys and even kill you. The risk of choking is there with the cinnamon challenge, but the risk is minuscule. So yeah...

  • 3

    Anna-Lisse

    5 years ago

    The cinnamon challenge is when u throw more than a tablespoon of cinnamon down your throat and possibly die. And the gallon challange is when you drink a gallon of milk. So the ? is would you rather die or puke I choose puking

    • 0

      Dilsifprosif

      2 years ago

      Do you know any reports of cinnamon challenge deaths tho?

  • 3

    SilverB33

    5 years ago

    I think it would be easier to down milk for me.

    • 2

      ossmosse

      4 years ago

      I've done both challenges and cinnamon challenge is wayy easier, gallon challenge gives you a stomach ache for a while :'(

    • 0

      ScoutTheUndying

      1 year ago

      I'm trying to imagine your profile picture chugging a gallon of milk. It's glorious.

  • 2

    Timmy

    1 year ago

    What would be in the gallon

  • 0

    Nitara

    1 week ago

    I did not know that you can die from the gallon challenge

  • 0

    Carolynn

    1 week ago

    Did you know Cinnamon could possibly kill you someone died from it eating it into her lungs and couldn't breathe or something like that...

  • 0

    Jacob, Son of Zeus

    1 week ago

    The cinnamon challenge is known to cause lung problems, I'd rather not take that chance.

  • 2

    fatso90

    4 years ago

    I successfully did the Cinnamon Challenge. :)

  • 2

    Harvcore_Robin

    4 years ago

    Cinnamon Challenge has killed, Gallon Challenge has made people throw up...

    • 2

      mikkelmob

      4 years ago

      the cinnamon challenge hasnt actually killed anyone. it has been close to but there is no reported deaths related to the cinnamon challenge.

  • 2

    Erika Rose Prince

    4 years ago

    Did the cinnamon challenge... was pretty easy

  • 2

    Conner Smith

    5 years ago

    I have tryed the milk thing. Lol Never again!

  • 2

    Jblover5050

    5 years ago

    How do u change ur pic???

  • 0

    whyamihere

    2 weeks ago

    both are stupid.

  • 0

    revenge of the toilets

    3 weeks ago

    You guys are idiots. Vomiting is way better then potential lung cancer

  • 0

    Siege2k9

    3 weeks ago

    3RD DEGREE BURNS PEOPLE

  • 0

    Yzal

    3 weeks ago

    Cinnamon is yummy.

  • 1

    corey

    1 year ago

    easy, dont breath

  • 1

    Nooby Niceston

    1 year ago

    cinnamon toast crunch anyone?

  • 1

    Coleman

    1 year ago

    I like milk

  • 0

    Paithen

    1 month ago

    Yeah, pick blue and suffocate. Nice.

  • 1

    kaige

    1 year ago

    i like cinamon

  • 1

    tburt1

    1 year ago

    dood i drink a glon of milk a day anyway big wup

  • 1

    _TheAnimeJinx_

    1 year ago

    the cinnamon challenge can dangerous for different people some people aren't able to get cinnamon down there throat. Especially me, I would probably choke to death considering the fact I cough a lot and sometimes wheeze because of my asthma.

  • 1

    Frank

    1 year ago

    Always wanted to try the gallon milk challenge with chocolate milk

  • 1

    Baliguti

    1 year ago

    Cinnamon

  • 0

    Tjmcnee

    1 month ago

    Not only you will be hydrated, but no longer hungry!

  • 0

    Tjmcnee

    1 month ago

    Not only you will be hydrated, but no longer hungry!

  • 0

    Tjmcnee

    1 month ago

    Cinnamon can choke you to death!

  • 0

    Tjmcnee

    1 month ago

    Cinnamon can choke you to death!

  • 0

    Alexa

    1 month ago

    malk

  • 0

    Starwalks Bro

    1 month ago

    Cinnamon gets stuck on your toung

  • 1

    Jamberry101

    2 years ago

    Guys, if you drink the milk slowly, you won't throw up. Iv'e tried it, trust me

  • 1

    droo46

    3 years ago

    Isn't there a chance you can die from the cinnamon challenge?

Load More

Tip: Sign up to see adult-rated questions.

Recently Answered

Either Mobile

Either is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android