Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

40% Give up Christmas

60% Give up your birthday

Would you rather...

40%
618,395 disagree
Give up Christmas
60%
939,848 agree
Give up your birthday

Presents

added by Rocks
Loading Comments…

If your birthday is Christmas you don't get either. If you don't celebrate Christmas, pick another gift related holiday (e.g. Hanukkah)

  • Meta Votes1,558,243 votes
  • Tags
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by Either moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

1,675 comments

  • 358

    groovykat

    8 years ago

    my birthdays aren't amazing anyway. On Christmas, I get presents from everyone, and I get that whole Christmas-y atmosphere, with the roast dinner and everyone being happy.

    • 44

      buttholio

      7 years ago

      Yeah, I don't get stuff for birthdays.

    • 58

      Mossy

      7 years ago

      Fuck. How do I change my mind?

    • 69

      Dragonite

      7 years ago

      I don't get anything from either and I am an Atheist. I'll just give up Christmas.

    • 5

      Marshall Clowater

      7 years ago

      shit i gave my answer b4 reading ur well thought out comment. though tbh my family isnt the best for christmas time so i guess it dont matter

    • 28

      sam

      7 years ago

      i am an athiest too but who cares if everyone gets presents

    • 27

      valcorwabajak

      7 years ago

      it does not matter if your an atheist Christmas isn't about family or Jesus it's about consumerism and getting shit... oh and drinking

    • 7

      Donut

      7 years ago

      I can celebrate Three KIngs Day.

    • 8

      jhizzle244

      7 years ago

      But in Africa, Children get a meal as their christmas present

    • 14

      BrentDH

      6 years ago

      My belief: when Christianity started getting old, they invented Christmas, especially for the kids. "Sure, son. You can be an Atheist. Just don't expect anything this Christmas."

    • 11

      Blueichigo

      6 years ago

      I agree. I love being with my family. I'd take opening presents with everyone and seeing their reactions over me being the center of attention.

    • 4

      Yanda Chen

      6 years ago

      Looool. I get what I want when i want

    • 19

      Fainting Goat

      6 years ago

      Does this mean I'll never age?

    • 2

      Elijah De Pino

      6 years ago

      The spending time with friends or family on christmas.

    • 7

      Ashley Huang

      6 years ago

      ...but...its nice when people say happy birthday to you...on your birthday

    • 3

      Corey Chang

      6 years ago

      Birthdays don't always give u the thing u want Christmas gives u the thing u always want. In other words, ANYTHING

    • 8

      SmartOne3

      6 years ago

      Is Christmas only about presents to you? I mean, the point of Christmas is CHRIST not goodies and eggnog.

    • 4

      kangcool09

      6 years ago

      I BELIEVE IN CHRIST AND STUFF,BUT MY BIRTHDAY IS THE DAY I GET DRUNK AND SOMETIMEZ BITCHEZ

    • 3

      kangcool09

      6 years ago

      @T.P.N GO MIND UR OWN RELIGION BECAUSE THATS WHAT I BELIEVE IN IF U CAN'T SAY ANYTHING NICE A BOUT IT U ARE BASICALLY BEING RAISIST

    • 3

      keasha

      6 years ago

      If u don't hav a birthday ur not on earth

    • 3

      keasha

      6 years ago

      If u don't hav a birthday ur not on earth

    • 5

      Redster120

      6 years ago

      would this mean that we won't age?

    • 2

      TrueWOPR

      5 years ago

      I celebrate the winter solstice so I'm not missing anything

    • 4

      Vieltrien

      5 years ago

      I hate Christmas anyways

    • 3

      AwesomeUniverse

      5 years ago

      You obviously give up your birthday because you don't want to get older but at Christmas it's all nice and presents and hot cocoa and crap.

    • 3

      Hero_Rareheart

      5 years ago

      I don't want to get older I'm moly a teenager and I miss being 3 already.

    • 2

      Cody Dudash

      5 years ago

      What if your birthday is on christmas?

    • 1

      Glaceon999

      5 years ago

      Miss ONE birthday. My brother may end up having that, in fact. Better miss one birthday than one christmas.

    • 1

      Jacob Dittmer

      5 years ago

      Beats not being born lol

    • 1

      Destroyah340

      5 years ago

      My birthdays always get overshadowed by the Super Bowl so it's not much of a loss

    • 1

      chaseman

      4 years ago

      same...

    • 1

      Htopop

      4 years ago

      Would I give up Chinese New Year too, if I chose Christmas.

    • 1

      blot

      4 years ago

      be jewish

    • 1

      FSK95

      4 years ago

      I don't celebrate Christmas. And I don't get any presents on my birthdays since I was 10. So it's good for me either way. And in my religion (ISLAM), we don't really care if we get no gifts in the celebrations.

    • 0

      Htopop

      4 years ago

      Hah, Chinese New Year suckas!

    • 0

      elliesse

      4 years ago

      Chrismas has no significance to me really its Jesus' birthday and we get gifts without a thought of him we should either use the day to pay respect or not at all if you dont believe in hi., a lot of holidays dont celebrate what its for, thanks giving (which i dont celebrate for being english) new years and valentines day are ones i can think of that do celebrate pretty right

    • 1

      ruben

      4 years ago

      true man i see where you come from

    • 2

      ThisIsSparta

      4 years ago

      If I gave up Christmas atleast there would be snow :/

    • 1

      Cindy

      3 years ago

      @groovykat, you are very lucky, I don't get much for christmas, have a "christmas-y" atmosphere or get a nice dinner.

    • 1

      Eduardo

      3 years ago

      True story

    • 1

      Eduardo

      3 years ago

      True story

    • 1

      roadrunner

      3 years ago

      my birthday is one month away from christmas (1/25) its like i actaully never had one

    • 0

      CatsRule

      3 years ago

      I'm a Darwinist, (I believe in evolution not some made up god crap)

    • 0

      CatsRule

      3 years ago

      screw all you selfish jerks >:(

    • 1

      Judd Nelson

      3 years ago

      If you didn't have a b-day, you don't exsist!!!

    • 1

      owen

      3 years ago

      ok dragonite

    • 2

      Joshua

      3 years ago

      I'm jewish

    • 1

      Ghi

      3 years ago

      I like Christmas and I'm catholic so yeah. And I also like all the lights and everything at Christmas. My birthday is 12-16

    • 0

      Gracyn

      3 years ago

      But u never age(marry have babies get a job collage a house)

    • 1

      Septiceye Sam

      3 years ago

      I don't celebrate my birthday and I never have. So this already applies to me.

    • 0

      FNAF

      3 years ago

      Fuck, how to change answer.

    • 1

      Macarena

      3 years ago

      I'm Muslim so yeah! :)

    • 1

      xander

      3 years ago

      but do you get a real party for christmas.

    • 2

      coolsawesome5

      3 years ago

      I've gotten a rock for my birthday

    • 2

      Randoman

      3 years ago

      Christmas has become so commercialized it's barely about Jesus and all that stuff. At this point it's just presents and Black Friday.

    • 2

      TheFracturedRuby

      3 years ago

      Christmas is the one time i can see my cousin in New York

    • 2

      John Jacula

      3 years ago

      my birthday is so close to xmas so presents from my bday count for christmas so it sucks

    • 2

      Luffy

      3 years ago

      I don't celebrate Christmas

    • 1

      Usernamecat123

      3 years ago

      My birthday is close to christmas and i dont get alot of presents from people other than my fam so....

    • 0

      Amelietheduck

      3 years ago

      im jewish. i got chanukah

    • 1

      Jon

      3 years ago

      My birthday sucks anyways. It is the day after Christmas and I get presents for both........

    • 1

      dude101thecooles

      3 years ago

      It's another of those selfless selfish kind of things. Plus Christmas rules, and preasants for everybody, not just me.

    • 1

      BaBooTube

      3 years ago

      "If your birthday is Christmas you don't get either. If you don't celebrate Christmas, pick another gift related holiday (e.g. Hanukkah)" -The Question Screw it! An Atheist can celebrate Hanukkah!

    • 1

      Breezy420

      3 years ago

      why would you give up you birthday for some mythical person your giving up the day to celebrate yourself to that. you all are retarted

    • 1

      BraZZers

      3 years ago

      i'm not christian

    • 1

      Norbert

      3 years ago

      Yeah, my birthday is never really celebrated anyway. Nobody really acknowledge's it anyway. Besides, Christmas = Christmas themed video games all around for a month!!!

    • 1

      FlameFern

      3 years ago

      BUT ... I don't celebrate Christmas

    • 0

      mickimic

      3 years ago

      me it is the contraire

    • 1

      I'll follow the sun

      3 years ago

      Be happy with your entire family and get the positive vibes of everyone being happy together. On birthdays, you're the center of attention, and I want to be happy giving to everyone.

    • 0

      Maple

      3 years ago

      i dont celebrate anything, too lazy and fricking boring anyway like whats the point

    • 1

      Awesome_Gamer

      3 years ago

      I like both, but I like Christmas more

    • 1

      king of animals

      3 years ago

      this is very hard man

    • 0

      noobhatts

      2 years ago

      Christmas=Family Yay Day

    • 0

      Tilly134

      2 years ago

      Well if I gave up my bday at like 15, then I would be a kid forever which would be so COOOOLLLLL!!!!!!! And plus Santa only comes to kids

    • 0

      Indigo M

      2 years ago

      @Tilly134 No, you don't understand... you would still age, but it wouldn't be celebrated and you wouldn't get any presents, or cake, or any of that fun stuff.

    • 0

      Moonpie116

      2 years ago

      MISS CLICKED PLS HELP BY GETTING THIS TOO THE TOP

    • 0

      Anonymous

      1 year ago

      Exactly, someone who gets me. I've got a similar opinion.

    • 0

      Bella

      1 year ago

      My birthday doesn't cost me.

  • 65

    horsedickdotmpeg

    7 years ago

    I'm atheist so...

    • 2

      Brdie

      7 years ago

      tuchey

    • 11

      Dudugs

      7 years ago

      birthdays suck after 10. and im a atheist and celebrate christmas

    • 4

      T.P.N

      6 years ago

      Christians stole X-mas from some other religion.

    • 2

      Moss Grande

      6 years ago

      Same but it's still a nice excuse to have a party with the rest of the world and be able to share presents.

    • 2

      StarswirlTheBearded

      6 years ago

      So am I but I still have X-mas.

    • 5

      Casey Burns

      5 years ago

      I'm athiest, celebrate christmas for the party, gifts and family, not the religious stuff......

    • 0

      Mike Buonomo

      5 years ago

      I just hate my family.

    • 0

      lemursocks

      5 years ago

      I'm atheist as well.

    • 1

      Jacob Dittmer

      5 years ago

      its spelled touche

    • 0

      CatsRule

      3 years ago

      I'm a Darwinist and don't celebrate Christmas so no loss for me :)

    • 1

      Shinyan

      3 years ago

      most athiests don't celebrate christmas?? I'm agnostic and still do?

    • 0

      doahou

      2 years ago

      I'm an atheist too but christmas is a holiday, I don't need to go to work, my birthday is just a shitty reminder that I'm growing old and am that much closer to death... and I need to go to work....

  • 36

    Jim

    10 years ago

    I needs me my Chris Kringle

  • 28

    [deleted]

    8 years ago

    birthdays suck after the age of 10 anyways

  • 27

    Cagri Omer Gomec

    7 years ago

    Muslim....

  • 19

    m9rfzzy

    8 years ago

    just became jewish >> then you get gifts for 8 days. Shalom motherfluffers

    • 5

      Angryhippie47

      7 years ago

      Hey retard it says that u cant hav another religous holiday

    • 9

      SageOfSixPaths

      7 years ago

      angryhippie, are u fucking blind? "If you don't celebrate Christmas, pick another gift related holiday (e.g. Hanukkah)"

    • 4

      Advance

      7 years ago

      You morons, you can't become Jewish.

    • 0

      some random guy

      7 years ago

      Sageofsixpacks I wanna shake ur hand :D

    • 6

      some random guy

      7 years ago

      Lol sixPATHS not sixpacks lol

    • 3

      Franklin Chen

      6 years ago

      @Advance Well some atheists like me celebrate christmas, so why not hanukkah

    • 0

      guycxz

      6 years ago

      I'm just going to pick another gift related holiday that I don't celebrate.

  • 18

    mintyfresh9080

    7 years ago

    (I only picked so I can comment) How do you give up your birthday? It will always be your birthday.

  • 16

    Nicholas D Wolfwood

    7 years ago

    I'm born on December 24th...so it's not like I lose much ground.

  • 14

    Kruegera

    6 years ago

    If I gave up my birthday, I would be effectively IMMORTAL.

  • 14

    courageoftheheart

    7 years ago

    Selfish, maybe, but my birthday is when I get the attention all on me! It's nice to get people kissing my feet once a year.

    • 0

      Vavakx

      4 years ago

      Don't have to give someone else gifts too.

  • 14

    youat2inthemorning

    8 years ago

    Christmas isn't the same anymore, the word christmas now means, PRESENTS.

    • 9

      Brdie

      7 years ago

      But Jesus's birthday still matters

    • 37

      youat2inthemorning

      7 years ago

      Well actually jesus was born during spring time not during winter, so yeah you got that wrong...

    • 7

      Petar Zivkovic

      7 years ago

      that's not true, it means presents and meat... plus if jesus did exist, his B-day would be somewhere in january

    • 5

      Nick

      7 years ago

      ruth, Jesus wasn't born in America >.

    • 12

      youat2inthemorning

      7 years ago

      Nick, I know jesus wasn't born in america.....

    • 13

      Nikolai T

      7 years ago

      Brdie, Jesus likely didn't exist, and he certainly wasn't divine. So, no, his (possible) birthday doesn't matter.

    • 8

      Bobby McBobz

      7 years ago

      Jesus is a fake christmas dos mean presents bitch!

    • 2

      qwert

      7 years ago

      to be fair most people don't care about it being christ's birthday it's morea time for family... WAY beater

    • 17

      youat2inthemorning

      7 years ago

      Time for families to get presents. ergo my comment

    • 3

      Anju

      7 years ago

      guys, Jesus was a real man! not divine but a man, there is historical proof. also, he was born in march.

    • 0

      youat2inthemorning

      7 years ago

      Wow anju you're late.

    • 6

      some random guy

      7 years ago

      Well while u guys debate this for the rest of ur life, I'm gonna go get layed :3

    • 6

      Jamie Piktel

      7 years ago

      *laid. Good for you.

    • 1

      Tanner

      7 years ago

      i agree. people are selfish now. i have friends that were wondering what to ask for christmas even before halloween

    • 2

      theset3

      6 years ago

      Christmas was stolen from Pagan tradition, so really you're all wrong!

    • 0

      Franklin Chen

      6 years ago

      Christmas is more of time of happiness And people like me love getting presents

    • 1

      cdog131

      5 years ago

      Do u believe In god

    • 0

      Taj Joh

      3 years ago

      @petar you're a special breed of stupid.

    • 3

      Hunter io

      3 years ago

      Stop fighting about Jesus

  • 11

    Brdie

    7 years ago

    Damn I didnt think! I thought oh my birthday is important day... Then I though "Oh thats Jesus's birthday" and already clicked :(

    • 0

      Void

      7 years ago

      @Jeremy yeah he is, he's doing my garden right now

  • 10

    Aryash

    6 years ago

    I get practically nothing from both.. oh well

  • 7

    Jousis

    7 years ago

    Christmas, at least 5 presents. Birthday, 1 present.

  • 6

    ori shalhon

    7 years ago

    just so you know..there are no gifts in hanukka

  • 6

    Cave Johnson

    7 years ago

    I get more presents at christmas, greedy fuck. I like it.

  • 6

    Zombiax

    7 years ago

    Fuck Jesus

    • 2

      keasha

      6 years ago

      Fuck u asshole u can't say "fuck Jesus" he is ur fucking savor

    • 1

      Alan A Gontes

      5 years ago

      You little cunt. Keep your comments to yourself because this offends people with certain religions. And they will be pissed

    • 0

      RandomGuy1466

      2 years ago

      YOU SATAN FAGGOT!

  • 6

    jwroth12

    8 years ago

    your birthday is YOUR day... you get to do what you want

    • 3

      Brdie

      7 years ago

      But christmas is the day Jesus was born I think that is more important

    • 14

      billmok

      7 years ago

      Brdie, nobody gives a fuck about Jesus.

    • 3

      G-ette

      7 years ago

      Jesus wasn't originally born on December 25th, it was moved to that day so that other religions who celebrated on that day would be pushed aside.

  • 5

    Sinarro

    6 years ago

    I don't even calibrate Christmas

    • 0

      Rain

      2 years ago

      Nor do you need to celibrate passing Reading class.

  • 5

    Brian Schwartz

    7 years ago

    Happy Hanukkah!

  • 5

    LOL FACE

    7 years ago

    what if your birthday is on Christmas

  • 4

    Imran Meco

    7 years ago

    I'm not christian anyway!

  • 4

    Federico Iglesias

    7 years ago

    same day

  • 4

    Ashley Shanks

    7 years ago

    Your birthday is just one day, Christmas seems to be a month long affair of happiness, food, and presents.

  • 4

    Kyndri Danger Hopkin

    7 years ago

    Immortality bitches. (I am assuming the by "give up" it means never have, and I would give up growing old.)

  • 3

    Austin Moseley

    6 years ago

    Haha my bday is Christmas Eve so I can still celebrate both in a way

  • 3

    dosh71099

    6 years ago

    I'm sorta Jewish so

  • 3

    chin776

    6 years ago

    Frickin Christian would give up Christmas that's sad I don't get as much at Christmas then my b-day plus my friends give my presents

  • 3

    redredredredredBLUE

    7 years ago

    I don't like christmas e.e

  • 3

    Maroua Naji

    7 years ago

    meh..my birthday's the same day as christmas...so i would give up any of them and it still makes no change

  • 3

    Blake Phelps

    7 years ago

    My Birthday is January 7 so i could get benefits for either one.

  • 3

    MaxRod

    7 years ago

    Thats a hard one.My birthday is on christmas!

  • 3

    sparta_the_cat

    7 years ago

    christmas is based on christianity (witch im not a part of but i celebrate anyway cause im a average person) and my birthday is my birthday

  • 3

    DeRpAsAuR

    7 years ago

    I don't celebrate my birthday anyway :l

  • 3

    ewill

    7 years ago

    Christmas is family time. My birthday is just awkward.

  • 3

    jazzhands

    8 years ago

    Let's face it, my birthday doesn't mean shit, while the Holiday season is a yearly international economic boost.

  • 0

    bill cage

    1 week ago

    i don't even celebrate christmas.

  • 2

    manorca

    5 years ago

    i had to choose but i dont do either of them

  • 2

    Chibs

    5 years ago

    Give up my birthday. The only people who ever say Happy birthday to me are my family. Or unless I mention it to someone, even then I only get a happy birthday 5% of the time.

  • 2

    Austin Moseley

    6 years ago

    Haha my bday is Christmas Eve so I can still celebrate both in a way

  • 2

    Ryan Reed

    6 years ago

    Would I be immortal because I would never age?0_0

  • 2

    Eik00c

    6 years ago

    My birthday is December 26, so I could've gone either way.

  • 2

    Yotam Steinitz

    6 years ago

    I'm Jewish

  • 2

    Ella Lahav

    6 years ago

    Hahaha I'm jewish =] no christmas anyway

  • 2

    jearmyclarckson

    6 years ago

    Im Jewish so it doesn't matter too much

  • 2

    Mother of Panda

    6 years ago

    I'm not even Christian

  • 2

    עדן לב

    6 years ago

    Jews

  • 2

    Salim Kaci

    6 years ago

    yay for being muslim i guess

  • 2

    Nutbar123

    6 years ago

    I'm Muslim soo...

  • 2

    Val

    7 years ago

    I am NOT giving up my birthday.. Christmas is Jesus' birthday anyway, I wouldn't give mine away for his >:(

Load More