Add Question

Question Title

Would you rather...

Blue Option
Red Option
 

 

Back to top

Would you rather...

37% be a character in Lord of the Rings

63% be a character in Harry Potter

Would you rather...

37%
377,130 agree
Be a character in Lord of the Rings
63%
645,698 disagree
Be a character in Harry Potter

Calling all Extras

added by blako923
Loading Comments…
Unmoderated: This question has not been reviewed by Either moderators. Content may be misformatted, offensive or inappropriate in nature.

680 comments

  • 249

    UguiSE

    4 years ago

    wtf is wrong with you ppl

    • 91

      Void

      4 years ago

      wtf is wrong with UguiSE I mean come on guiSE

    • 48

      Gabora

      4 years ago

      you could be an ordinary-skilled character while in the harry potter unierse if you're a common wizard it's still the shit

    • 29

      erik

      4 years ago

      wait...Gabora...you can still be a regular human...

    • 25

      Denivire

      4 years ago

      Gabora, you could end up being Dudley or equivalent. That'd suck.

    • 17

      Alvo Razzi

      4 years ago

      So? you wouldn't have a choice in the matter I presume. you can't choose what you would be born as. besides, there's no wartime danger and thousands dying but there's still action and adventure along with girls! (or guys!). You get to use magic too.

    • 75

      Scourge

      4 years ago

      Black Riders, Nazguls, Orcs, Goblins, Middle Earth, Hobbits, The Shire, Better Magic, Trolls, and Dwarfs over Teenage, newbie wizards, some bald guy with no nose, weak trolls, wands are the only weapons, and its a school? FUCK THAT SHIT

    • 22

      Ford Williams

      4 years ago

      I'd rather use magic at home then in middle earth.

    • 52

      valcorwabajak

      4 years ago

      Gandolf would kick Dumbledore's ass

    • 11

      Wade Tyrpin

      4 years ago

      Can we choose which character? If so, I choose Gandalf.

    • 18

      TheMacaroon

      4 years ago

      MAGIC, or swords?

    • 31

      Milk Stain

      4 years ago

      Theres Magic in Lord of the rings too....

    • 6

      Mary

      3 years ago

      dont hate me ive never seen lord of the rings but i did see the hobbit

    • 17

      Luis Hernandez

      3 years ago

      Hardest decision of my life. I swear. I love LotR, but my childhood was Harry Potter. Sorry

    • 14

      [deleted]

      3 years ago

      LEGOLAS

    • 12

      Bassist100

      3 years ago

      Most of these idiots probably don't know what LotR is

    • 7

      Epicness

      3 years ago

      Why not both? But gandalf can go YOU SHALL NOT PASS Harry can't too that

    • 8

      Magic

      3 years ago

      "May the force be with you, harry" -Gandalf

    • 5

      BALisTIc

      3 years ago

      one word legoles

    • 10

      MeGustaL0T

      3 years ago

      LEGOLAS! ARAGORN! GANDALF! Fuck you Harry Potter Bitchy Dick suckers!!!!!!!!!!!

    • 1

      Micah Frazier

      3 years ago

      I hate both I just picked the one with most character development in the entire series

    • 8

      Cody Dudash

      3 years ago

      You sir, are a horrible person. Got sit in the corner and think about what you have done.

    • 6

      Latios Bombadil

      3 years ago

      Tom Bombadil will pwn you all!!!

    • 5

      Darth Shade

      2 years ago

      Why can't we just all respect other people's opinions and stop complaining

    • 6

      Lunatic

      1 year ago

      Balrog ftw

    • 7

      Joel

      1 year ago

      One does not simply walk into Mordor

    • 2

      Bowen

      1 year ago

      I would be more definitely dead in lord of the rings, maybe I'll just be some student in ravenclaw and live.

    • 6

      Ragnarokdragon

      1 year ago

      I'd be Gandolf just to say "you shall not pass!"

    • 3

      SmarterThanYou

      1 year ago

      There's medieval fantasy and magic fantasy. Magic almost always wins.

    • 2

      Mckaos

      1 year ago

      Harry potter universe is 10x more boring. You can be a wizard or a knight in LOTR, but you can only be a wizard in Harry Potter.

    • 2

      JenceDaGeek

      1 year ago

      @Milk Stain there's barely any magic! Only the wizards ever get to use it!

    • 1

      CMan

      1 year ago

      agree

    • 3

      lilzaratata

      1 year ago

      Just think of all the epic battles you can have when fighting in middle earth. You're fighting an orc army and then outta nowhere, a Mûmakil appears

    • 2

      PebblePanda

      1 year ago

      I want the world where the internet exists :3

    • 2

      Jacob

      1 year ago

      Their never going to make another harry potter movie so no sense in being a character on one..

    • 2

      TehFudd

      1 year ago

      LORD OF THE RINGS OVER HARRY POTTER ANY DAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • 1

      Russell Coight

      11 months ago

      Emma watson is the only positive about harry potter but there is plenty of good puss available in middle earth

    • 0

      The Delta Snivy

      10 months ago

      LOTR FTW

    • 1

      John Cena

      10 months ago

      Harry FTW

    • 1

      Tilia

      9 months ago

      on lord of the rings theres so much death and shit, in harry potter you can come back and be all like "suprise" i mean gandalf did and he is a wizard, wizard=harry potter

    • 0

      Flurble Blur

      6 months ago

      You'd be dead.

    • 0

      zunaam

      5 months ago

      harry potter is much cooler like wtf gandalf he ruind everything by coming back alive like really realy just com on we can ride brooms we can like do suprise mother fucka and do spell andhave ginny to fuck and get albus

    • 1

      HopeyousteponaLego

      5 months ago

      Spells and Magic>Whatever.

    • 0

      JBadger

      5 months ago

      If you're an ordinary person in Harry Potter nothing changes and your life is the same. If your an ordinary person in Lord of the Rings, you have to deal with actual monsters no matter what.

    • 0

      Tansa

      5 months ago

      Depends on who I become

    • 0

      Ewan

      5 months ago

      Id be fucking Voldemort

    • 0

      Matyu

      5 months ago

      I like both,but in Harry Potter is more magic and I can beat dat stupid evil Voldemort

    • 0

      Rose

      3 months ago

      UMM. WHAT WRONG WITH YOOOOOOUU

    • 0

      Carra_Luzi

      2 months ago

      dude shut up harry potter is the best

    • 0

      Springlocked84

      1 week ago

      exactly. great question

  • 71

    W!ND0L!CK3R

    4 years ago

    harry potter is a fag

    • 34

      Lydia Jaye

      4 years ago

      boo your face

    • 19

      Austin2050

      4 years ago

      AVADA KEDAVRA! To you as well.

    • 5

      gone

      4 years ago

      A much bigger chance of dying in lotr.

    • 2

      palkia684

      3 years ago

      Shut up! Colloportus!

    • 7

      Anna De Serio

      3 years ago

      Muggle

    • 3

      [deleted]

      3 years ago

      I wouldn't say he's a fag, but I do love LOTR

    • 5

      Sapple

      3 years ago

      Well, he IS homosexual, and the slang, albeit much more rude, term for homosexual is "fag."

    • 3

      BALisTIc

      3 years ago

      harry potter is a stupid wizard with stupid spectecles and a stupid stick....iam not swearing this time fuckers

    • 0

      MeGustaL0T

      3 years ago

      Harry potter sucks dick you fucking fag heads. I agree with ALL BLUE! Harry potter is a short pussy bitch.

    • 1

      Edward Fellow

      3 years ago

      You can't be Harry Potter, just a characters in the universe.

    • 0

      Wheatley33

      1 year ago

      and going to the hall of Mandos? that'd be fine

    • 2

      SmarterThanYou

      1 year ago

      That's a lie and you know it.

    • 0

      lilzaratata

      1 year ago

      @SmarterThanYou you're a lie and you know it

    • 0

      Matyu

      5 months ago

      AVA KEDAVRA!!!!!!!!!!

  • 49

    Chuck Norris

    4 years ago

    YOU!!!!....SHALL NOT!!!!!.....PASS!!!!!!!!

    • 4

      StarTreck

      4 years ago

      THx for taking my answer xD

    • 3

      MeGustaL0T

      3 years ago

      GAANNNNDAAAAALLLFFFF!!!!

    • 0

      peeein

      2 years ago

      Me: your a wizard chuck Chuck: I fucking knew that

    • 0

      Joel

      1 year ago

      One does not simply walk into mordor

    • 0

      Pikachu

      1 year ago

      YUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUS BEST REFRENC EVAHHH (BTW I SAW IT ON TEH LEGO GAME THINGY MAGIG) DONT JUDGE MEH ENGLISHHHHHHH

    • 0

      Matyu

      5 months ago

      I will say Alohomora to open your head!!!!!!

  • 35

    Stefan Pantić-Panta

    4 years ago

    Lord of the rings os the best story of all time

  • 20

    Brian Kyle

    4 years ago

    A lot of stupid people

  • 19

    Linkums

    4 years ago

    Middle Earth is too dangerous and filled with doom for my tastes.

    • 6

      Katie

      3 years ago

      But there are a bunch of wizards that could turn evil at any moment and just murder everyone. XD Also, what if you had to be a muggle? D=

    • 0

      peeein

      2 years ago

      then not much different from real life Katie

    • 0

      Owen

      11 months ago

      Harry Potter? HELL YEAH

  • 16

    Stefan Pantić-Panta

    4 years ago

    Lord of the rings os the best story of all time

  • 15

    courageoftheheart

    4 years ago

    The likelihood of death is significantly lower in Lord of the Rings, I think. J.K. Rowling's writing just reads "I don't even give a crap anymore" later on.

  • 10

    Brendan Butler

    4 years ago

    LOTR is at least cool. Harry potter fucking sucks. And LOTR has Boromir

  • 9

    Caroline Tan

    4 years ago

    WHAAAAA?!?! IT'S ALL ABOUT MIDDLE EARTH!!!!!

  • 8

    Pekka Säkkinen

    4 years ago

    I'd be a Hobbit living in the Shire in peace. And then a random fucking wizard smokin' pot would come and take me to an adventure^^.

    • 1

      James

      1 year ago

      Nii ja sä saattaisit myös olla joku örkki joka yrittää tappaa kaikki :D

  • 8

    ironphan24

    4 years ago

    D: NO ONE should hate on lord of the rings

  • 8

    Joe Mama

    4 years ago

    One does not simply kill Voldemort by going back in time with Hermines time traveling watch.

  • 8

    Felipe Benatti Serma

    4 years ago

    I love LOTR, but I dont wanna be an orc... and everybody in HP world's a wizard

    • 30

      [deleted]

      4 years ago

      Not true. First you have Muggles, non magical humans. Then you have giants, trolls, centaurs, pixies, dememtors, mer people, ghosts, hippogriffs, dragons, phoenix's, Goblins, house elves, and a whole list of other creatures.

    • 20

      ironphan24

      4 years ago

      why don't u be an elf, man, dwarf, hobbit, or wizard???

    • 5

      Yuiopy

      4 years ago

      Filch is a squib. He can't do magic.

    • 11

      Alicia Laing

      4 years ago

      Hobbits? There is more to middle earth then orc's

    • 3

      zoop

      3 years ago

      you could still be a wizard

    • 1

      BALisTIc

      3 years ago

      have a stick or a axe,bow,sword,mini sword,staff and magical hands?

    • 0

      AidanIsMe

      1 year ago

      What about normal people? And there are a million (give or take) races in LOTR

  • 7

    ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

    4 years ago

    Wtf. 62% Harry Potter? You're telling me you're gonna miss out on those epic battles just to be a wizard? :o

  • 6

    Chaotic_Narwhal

    3 years ago

    I hope you all become muggles and have to watch all the wizards have fun

  • 6

    Anadwen

    3 years ago

    what's wrong with 222, 638 people? I mean, a sword can cut a wand into pieces... and if you'd get to be an elf, you'd be immortal, extremely beautiful, with awesome senses and everything... what is a hundred times better than going to some lame school for lame teen wizards.

    • 1

      James

      1 year ago

      Well whit wand you can make a giant firestorm like Dumbledore did in Half-blood Prince. But i dont dislike LotR it's wery good story. :P

  • 6

    DarkKnight64

    4 years ago

    What?! Lord of the Rings is a better series, and a way better movie series.

  • 6

    Wiggles

    4 years ago

    this question is not fair.

  • 6

    Traktornator

    4 years ago

    Thinking of my love for food, tobacco, beer, parties and the fact that I am very short, I'd probably be a hobbit, and how cool isn't that? And even if I didn't end up as a hobbit, it'd still be cool because I'm in fucking Middle-earth.

  • 6

    Flávio Sousa

    4 years ago

    As much as I like Harry Potter...

  • 6

    Harry Potter

    4 years ago

    Im Going With Lord Of The Rings

  • 6

    NoJimmyProtested

    4 years ago

    Being magical and British accents.....guys it doesn't get better than that aha

    • 1

      Hudson

      1 year ago

      gay, you'd probably suck dumbledore's dick.

  • 5

    Avery

    1 year ago

    Imma go off to Rivendell now, Galu! Savo 'lass a lalaith!

  • 5

    Franklin Chen

    4 years ago

    WTF? Lord of the Rings is an epic fantasy classic! HP nerds...

  • 5

    Muffin

    4 years ago

    You assholes disappoint me.

  • 4

    Vivi Adamová

    4 years ago

    cmon ppl HOBBITS ARE CUTE!

  • 4

    Timewalker

    4 years ago

    Sauron or Gandalf! (Or Frodo because of the ring.)

  • 4

    Sunderlandfan99

    4 years ago

    This makes me extremely sad. Harry Potter wasn't even very good and Lord of the Rings is awesome.

  • 4

    abcpo55

    4 years ago

    I am surprised and disappointed at the number of people who betrayed the LOTR. Harry Potter has to thank J.R.R Tolkien for so many of the things it emulated from wonderful middle earth! ...Sorry for the Nerd rage guys.

  • 4

    Jazmeow

    4 years ago

    Who wouldn't want to live in a world with a sexy elf version of Orlando Bloom?

  • 4

    Seiber 69er

    4 years ago

    One does not simply pick red without being gay. Harry potter likes to play with magic wands all day (if you know what i mean)

  • 4

    Chip Davis

    4 years ago

    be a derp who can do magic, and only when holding a stick....or be a badass sword-wielding troll-killer.....Also, Lord of the Rings has more class.

  • 4

    pheonix

    4 years ago

    i would try and walk into mordor

  • 4

    Harry Potter

    4 years ago

    Im Going With Lord Of The Rings

  • 3

    Lynnaya Hamby

    3 years ago

    Seriously? A wizard in the modern world or a warrior in the middle ages? How can you even ask that?!

  • 3

    Chaotic_Narwhal

    3 years ago

    Plus lotr is way more intricate and detailed

  • 3

    Martymcchew

    3 years ago

    How would you not want to be in Middle earth, forget broomsticks and wands, how about dragons, staffs, swords, axes, Hobbits, Elves, Dwarves ect, even if you were a normal human you could still use some magic and master weapon skills (I've found my people in the comment section)

  • 3

    Odd

    3 years ago

    Legolas!

  • 3

    DIlhaus

    4 years ago

    I just think the adventure that comes with LOTR would be way more fun. Id be slayin some bitches.

  • 3

    Saruman

    4 years ago

    You're all unworthy of Middle Earth & you're not welcome here. P.S. Who yu think taught Dumbledore how to comb his long beards, eh??

  • 3

    Anna

    4 years ago

    I'd be married to Legolas Greenleaf of the woodland realm

  • 3

    LordTetris

    4 years ago

    Harry, Hermoine, and Ron would just take up most of the story anyways.

  • 1

    LukeTheDuke

    3 months ago

    You're a harry, wizard

  • 1

    Hydrafire

    3 months ago

    I want to kill some uruks

  • 0

    TheReasonableChoice

    1 week ago

    F*uck bows! I have magic!

  • 0

    TheReasonableChoice

    1 week ago

    F*uck bows! I have magic!

  • 2

    Nist Comun

    3 years ago

    LotR rules

  • 2

    Behind The Wall Adventure

    3 years ago

    2 Words : Martin Freeman

  • 2

    hairen

    3 years ago

    Lord of the rings is epic Harry potter is meh

Load More

Tip: Use the arrow keys to navigate between questions.

Recently Answered

Either Mobile

Either is available for free on iOS and Android. You're welcome.

For iOS For Android