Would you rather...

Go to heaven or hell

Be reborn into a better/worse life

Where you go depends on how you lived (good/bad life).

The Afterlife

Oct 4, 2009

VintageLife

Community arguments

Go to heaven or hell

Choosing to live ethically gives you direct influence over your eternal destination — the outcome is something you can actively work toward
Even an undesirable eternal destination offers the company of history's greatest thinkers, artists, and rebels
Divine forgiveness built into many theological frameworks means mistakes do not automatically seal your fate forever

Be reborn into a better/worse life

Eternal punishment for finite mistakes is disproportionate; reincarnation always offers another life and a fresh chance to improve
Reincarnation has no strict gatekeeper, no demanding ruleset to follow, and no risk of permanent damnation — just a reset
Even a worse next life eventually ends and resets again, while eternal hellfire offers no exit and no second chances

Last generated Jun 29, 2026.

Comments

Would you rather...

Go to heaven or hell

Be reborn into a better/worse life