Would you rather...

kill a 5 year old girl's puppy

kill old lady's cat

If it was the 5 year old she would cry like all day but might get a new one when the 55 year old why would most likey die of sadess or something idk :P

A Girl's Pet

Aug 9, 2012

VintageAnimals Violence

Community arguments

kill a 5 year old girl's puppy

An elderly person's pet may be their only companion; its death close to end of life could be devastating
A young child encountering loss early can develop resilience and empathy, turning grief into a formative experience

kill old lady's cat

Young children are especially vulnerable to lasting psychological harm from traumatic loss; sparing them is a priority
An older person has more life experience and emotional resources to process grief than a 5-year-old does

Last generated Jun 29, 2026.

Comments

Would you rather...

kill a 5 year old girl's puppy

kill old lady's cat