Would you rather...

Live in a nudist colony

Live with the Amish

You would have to be a participating member in either lifestyle

The Naked Amish

Oct 5, 2009

VintageLife

Community arguments

Live in a nudist colony

Nudist colonies still have all the technology, entertainment, and modern comforts that make daily life worthwhile.
Exposure to nudity normalizes within days — the awkwardness fades and life otherwise continues exactly as before.
Being Amish means losing the internet, electricity, and modern medicine — sacrifices far beyond mere social discomfort.

Live with the Amish

Amish communities offer genuine self-sufficiency, deep social bonds, and a quieter pace that technology-saturated modern life rarely provides.
Without constant screens and digital noise, Amish life forces the present-moment engagement many people spend their whole lives trying to find.
Practical Amish skills — farming, craftsmanship, community — provide a resilience and security that comfort-dependent modern living lacks.

Last generated Jun 29, 2026.

Comments

Would you rather...

Live in a nudist colony

Live with the Amish