Would you rather be extremely unattractive or extremely attractive, but have a hand that smells like poop?

Poophand · Either

be extremely unattractive

A permanent, uncoverable poop smell actively repels people even in trusted relationships — unattractiveness affects first impressions but leaves all other senses intact.
Appearance can be partially improved through fitness, style, and confidence; an uncoverable body odor is a fixed condition with no workaround.
Unattractiveness is visible mainly at first glance; a persistent foul smell follows you into every intimate, professional, and social setting without exception.

be extremely attractive, but have a hand that smells perpetually like poop

Being extremely attractive opens social, romantic, and professional doors that extreme unattractiveness permanently closes — most people will tolerate or overlook the smell.
One smelly hand is a single, contained drawback; being extremely unattractive affects every first impression, every interview, and every social interaction across your entire life.
Attractiveness confers enormous, compounding advantages — better opportunities, more social trust, more relationships — that no amount of personality can fully substitute.